The language literature contains many citations to Skinner's book Verbal Behavior (1957), however, most of them are negative and generally unsupportive. The current list of references was assembled to bring readers in contact with the growing body of literature which supports Skinner's work. A total of 136 references were found and divided into two categories, (1) conceptual, and (2) experimental and applied. These references are presented in an effort to stimulate additional research in this important aspect of behavior analysis.

ResearchGate Logo

Discover the world's research

  • 20+ million members
  • 135+ million publications
  • 700k+ research projects

Join for free

The

Analysis

of

Verbal

Behavior

1982,

1,

9-13

Skinner's

Verbal

Behavior:

A

Reference

List

Mark

L.

Sundberg

and

James

W.

Partington

Regional

Center

of

the

East

Bay

Oakland,

CA

The

language

literature

contains

many

citations

to

Skinner's

book

Verbal

Behavior

(1957),

however,

most

of

them

are

negative

and

generally

unsupportive.

The

current

list

of

references

was

assembled

to

bring

readers

in

contact

with

the

growing

body

of

literature

which

supports

Skinner's

work.

A

total

of

136

references

were

found

and

divided

into

two

categories,

(1)

conceptual,

and

(2)

experimental

and

applied.

These

references

are

presented

in

an

effort

to

stimulate

additional

research

in

this

important

aspect

of

behavior

analysis.

Skinner's

book

Verbal

Behavior

(1957)

has

been

available

for

25

years,

yet

relatively

little

use

has

been

made

of

the

analysis

or

con-

cepts

contained

in

that

book.

The

literature

on

language

does

contain

many

citations

to

the

book,

but

most

of

them

are

negative

and

unsupportive

of

Skinner's

work.

Many

of

these

negative

references

can

be

traced

back

to

Chomsky's

(1959)

widely

cited

review

of

Verbal

Behavior.

Neisser

(1967),

for

example,

writes

"Chomsky's

32

page

review

of

Verbal

Behavior

is

far

more

than

effective

refutation

of

the

behavioristic

approach

to

language"

(p.

246).

Unfortunately,

the

number

of

negative

citations

seems

to

outweigh

the

number

of

positive

citations,

and

as

Richelle

(1976)

has

pointed

out,

many

have

simply

dispensed

with

reading

the

book

or

related

work.

However,

many

people

have

read

Skin-

ner's

book

and

found

it

to

be

an

outstanding

treatment

of

the

topic

of

language.

Some

of

these

people

have

carried

on

Skinner's

work

with

further

analyses,

and/or

with

empirical

research

and

applications.

The

following

col-

lection

of

references

was

assembled

to

pro-

vide

the

reader

with

a

list

of

some

of

that

work.

There

are

two

categories

of

references

included,

(1)

conceptual,

and

(2)

experimen-

tal

and

applied.

The

criterion

used

for

indu-

sion

of

conceptual

material

was

that

the

paper

contained

a

positive

or

constructive

discussion

or

development

of

some

aspect

of

Skinner's

Verbal

Behavior.

Other

sources

which

were

negative

or

anti-behavioral

were

excluded

due

to

general

misconceptions,

or

due

to

a

lack

of

a

thorough

analysis

of

the

relevant

issues.

Also,

citing

every

article

that

criticizes

Verbal

Behavior

would

take

up

too

much

space

and

not

contribute

much

to

the

development

of

the

behavioral

analysis

of

language.

Chomsky

(1959)

and

Place

(1981a,

1981b)

are

exceptions.

They

are

included

to

provide

the

reader

with

a

sample

of

how

the

book

is

typically

misinterpreted.

Experimental

and

applied

research

on

Skinner's

analysis

of

verbal

behavior

was

a

little

more

difficult

to

compile.

The

literature

(especially

the

applied)

contains

many

studies

which

adhere

to

the

"behavioral

view

of

language"

but

in

a

review

of

JABA

and

related

publications

Knapp

(1980)

concludes:

for

the

most

part

this

line

of

research

ignores

the

written

work

Verbal

Behavior

and

on

one

occasion

approaches

dismissal

by

referring

to

Verbal

Behavior

as

theory,

placing

it

in

the

category

of

Chomsky's

and

Lenneberg's

work.

I

get

the

feel-

ing

that

as

valuable,

and

on

occasion

as

relevant

as

this

line

of

research

is,

it

most

likely

would

have

occurred

given

only

The

Behavior

of

Organisms

(p.

190).

Much

of

the

applied

work

does

indeed

use

behavioral

principles

and

procedures

to

study

language,

but

as

Knapp

points

out,

they

fail

to

make

use

of

a

behavioral

analysis

of

the

contingencies

involved

for

the

indi-

vidual

speaker.

Hence,

behavioral

methods

are

often

used

to

study

traditional

linguistic

concepts

which

are

often

irrelevant

from

Skinner's

point

of

view.

The

criteria

for

inclusion

in

the

research

section

were

(1)

the

paper

referenced

Skin-

ner

(1957),

and

(2)

some

aspect

of

the

paper

centered

around

the

investigation

or

applica-

tion

of

a

feature

of

Skinner's

book

(e.g.,

the

functional

independence

of

the

mand

and

the

tact;

teaching

an

intraverbal

repertoire).

9

10

MARK

L.

SUNDBERG

AND

JAMES

W.

PARTINGTON

A

review

of

the

14

volumes

of

JABA

turned

up

16

papers

which

cited

the

1957

text

but

only

8

made

some

use

of

the

analysis

in

their

study.

(One

article

contained

the

1957

reference

in

the

bibliography

but

it

failed

to

appear

anywhere

in

the

text.)

Other

sources

were

also

checked,

but

the

ABA

program

books

and

the

authors'

collection

of

papers

and

reprints

from

other

researchers

provided

many

of

the

citations.

We

would

like

to

emphasize

that

this

reference

list

be

viewed

as

a

beginning

to

the

collection

of

work

on

Skinner's

Verbal

Behavior,

and

hope

that

this

collection

will

offset

the

overwhelming

presence

of

negative

literature,

as

well

as

stimulate

addi-

tional

research

in

this

very important

aspect

of

behavior

analysis.

CONCEPTUAL

REFERENCES

Bennett,

M.

L.

(1978).

A

conceptual

analysis

of

radical

behaviorist

epistemology.

Unpublished

Master's

Thesis,

Western

Michigan

University.

Burton,

M.

(1980).

Determinism,

relativism

and

the

behavior

of

scientists.

Behaviorism,

8,

113-122.

Catania,

A.

C.

(1972).

Chomsky's

formal

analysis

of

natural

language:

A

behavioral

translation.

Behaviorism,

1,

1-5.

Catania,

A.

C.

(1973).

The

psychologies

of

structure,

function

and

development.

American

Psychologist,

28,

431-443.

Catania,

A.

C.

(1980).

Autoclitic

processes

and

the

struc-

ture

of

behavior.

Behaviorism,

8,

175-186.

Chomsky,

N.

(1959).

A

review

of

Verbal

behavior,

by

B.

F.

Skinner.

Language,

35,

26-58.

Costall,

A.

(1980).

The

limits

of

language:

Wittgenstein's

later

philosophy

and

Skinner's

radical

behaviorism.

Behaviorism,

8,

123-131.

Day,

W

F.

(1969a).

On

certain

similarities

between

the

philosophical

investigations

of

Ludwig

Wittgenstein

and

the

operationism

of

B.

F.

Skinner.

Journal

of

Ex-

perimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

12,

489-506.

Day,

W

F.

(1969b).

Radical

behaviorism

in

reconciliation

with

phenomenology.

Journal

of

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

12,

315-328.

Day,

W.

F.

(1971,

September).

Methodological

problems

in

the

analysis

of

behavior

controlled

by

private

events:

Some

unusual

recommendations.

Paper

presented

at

79th

An-

nual

Meeting

of

the

American

Psychological

Associa-

tion,

Washington,

D.

C.

Day,

W.

F.

(1976).

Contemporary

behaviorism

and

the

concept

of

intention.

In

J.

K.

Cole

&

W

J.

Arnold

(Eds.),

Nebraska

Symposium

on

Motivation

(pp.

65-131).

Lincoln:

University

of

Nebraska

Press.

Day,

W.

F.

(1980).

Some

comments

on

the

book

Verbal

behavior,

Behaviorism,

8,

165-173.

Hefferline,

R.

(1947/1980).

Class

notes

on

a

course

in

ver-

bal

behavior

by

B.

F.

Skinner.

Western

Michigan Univer-

sity,

Behavioral

Monograph

#3,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Karen,

R.

L.

(1975).

An

introduction

to

behavior

theory

and

its

applications.

New

York:

Harper

&

Row.

Kendler,

H. H.

(1959).

Learning.

In

P.

R.

Farnsworth

and

Q.

McNemar

(Eds.),

Annual

Review

of

Psychology

(pp.

43-88).

Palo

Alto,

Ca:

Annual

Reviews,

Inc.

Kitchener,

R.

F.

(1975).

Behavior

and

behaviorism,

Behaviorism,

5,

11-71.

Knapp,

T.

J.

(1980).

Beyond

Verbal

behavior,

Behaviorism,

8,

187-194.

Lahren,

B.

(1976).

Commentary

on

Margolis'

paper

"Mental

States."

Behaviorism,

4,

77-95.

Lee,

V.

L.

(1981).

Terminological

and

conceptual

revision

in

the

experimental

analysis

of

language

development:

Why.

Behaviorism,

9,

25-53.

MacCorqudale,

K.

(1969).

B.

F.

Skinner's

Verbal

behavior:

A

retrospective

appreciation.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

12,

831-841

MacCorqudale,

K.

(1970).

On

Chomsky's

review

of

Verbal

behavior.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

13,

83-99.

McLeish,

J.,

&

Martin,

J.

(1975).

Verbal behavior:

A

review

and

experimental

analysis.

Journal

of

General

Psychology,

93,

3-66.

Michael,

J.

L.

(1980).

Untitled

presentation.

Behaviorism,

8,

161-163.

--

Michael,

J.

L.

(1982).

Distinguishing

between

discriminative

and

motivational

functions

of

stimuli.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

37,

149-155.

Michael,

J.

L.

(1982).

Objectives

and

exams

for

a

course

us-

ing

B.

F.

Skinner's

book

Verbal

behavior.

Available

upon

request

Department

of

Psychology,

Westem

Midcigan

University,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Moore,

J.

(1980).

On

behaviorism

and

private

events.

Psychological

Record,

30,

459-475.

Moore,

J.

(1981).

On

mentalism,

methodological

behaviorism

and

radical

behaviorism.

Behaviorism,

9,

55-77.

Morris,

C.

(1958).

Verbal

behavior,

by

B.F.

Skinner.

Con-

temporary

Psychology,

3,

212-214.

Osgood,

C.

E.

(1958).

Verbal

behavior,

by

B.F.

Skinner.

Contemporary

Psychology,

3,

209-212.

Peterson,

N.

(1978).

An

introduction

to

verbal

behavior,

Grand

Rapids,

MI:

Behavior

Associates.

Place,

U.

T.

(1981a).

Skinner's

Verbal

behavior

I:

Why

we

need

it.

Behaviorism,

9,

1-24.

Place,

U.

T.

(1981b).

Skinner's

Verbal

behavior

II:

What's

wrong

with

it.

Behaviorism,

9,

131-152.

Richelle,

M.

(1976).

Formal

analysis

and

functional

analysis

of

verbal

behavior:

Notes

on

the

debate

bet-

ween

Chomsky

and

Skinner.

Behaviorism,

4,

209-221.

Salzinger,

K.

(1959).

Experimental

manipulation

of

ver-

bal

behavior:

A

review.

Journal

of

General

Psychology,

60,

65-94.

Salzinger,

K.

(1978).

Language

behavior.

In

A.

C.

Catania

&

T.

A.

Brigham

(Eds.),

Handbook

of

applied

behavior

analysis:

Social

and

instructional

processes

(pp.

275-321).

New

York:

Irvington.

Salzinger,

K.,

&

Salzinger,

K.

S.

(1967).

Research

in

ver-

bal

behavior

and

some

neurophysiological

implications

(Eds.),

New

York:

Academic

Press.

Sapon,

S.

M.

(1981,

May).

Taking

Occam's

razor

to

verbal

behavior:

A

descriptive

analysis

of

verbal

behavior.

Presented

at

the

Seventh

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Milwaukee,

WI.

Schnaitter,

R.

(1978).

Private

causes.

Behaviorism,

6,

1-12.

SKINNER'S

VERBAL

BEHAVIOR:

A

REFERENCE

LIST

11

Schnaitter,

R.

(1980).

Science

and

verbal

behavior.

Behaviorism,

8,

153-160.

Schoenfeld,

W.

N.

(1969).

J.

R.

Kantor's

Objective

psychology

of

grammar

and

psychology

and

logic:

A

retrospective

appreciation.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

12,

329-347.

Segal,

E.

F.

(1975).

Psycholinguistics

discovers

the

operant:

A

review

of

Roger

Brown's

A

first

language:

The

early

stages.

lournal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

23,

149-158.

Segal,

E.

F.

(1977).

Toward

a

coherent

psychology

of

language

in

W.

K.

Honig

&

J.

E.

R.

Staddon

(Eds.),

Handbook

of

operant

behavior

(pp.

628-653).

Englewood

Cliffs,

NJ:

Prentice-Hall.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1953).

Science

and

human

behavior.

New

York:

The

Free

Press.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1957).

Verbal

behavior.

Englewood

Cliffs,

NJ:

Prentice-Hall.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1971).

Beyond

freedom

and

dignity.

New

York:

Knopf.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1972).

Cumulative

record

(3rd

Ed.).

Englewood

Cliffs,

NJ:

Prentice-Hall.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1974).

About

behaviorism.

New

York:

Knopf.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1978).

Reflections

on

behaviorism

and

society.

Englewood

Cliffs,

NJ:

Prentice-Hall.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1947/1980).

The

William

James

Lectures.

(Harvard

University).

Western

Michigan

University

Behavioral

Monograph

#4,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Skinner,

B.

F.

(1980).

Notebooks.

Englewood

Cliffs,

NJ:

Prentice-Hall.

Sulzbacher,

S.

I.,

&

Oller,

D.

K.

(1974).

A

reanalysis

of

Lenneberg's

Biological

foundations

of

language.

Behav-

iorism,

2,

146-161.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Michael,

J.

L.,

&

Peterson,

N.

(1980).

Sign

Language:

A

behavioral

analysis

and

applica-

tions.

Western

Michigan

University

Behavioral

Monograph

#5,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Ray,

D.

A.,

&

Rueber,

T.

M.

(1980).

Issues

in

language

research.

Western

Michigan

Univer-

sity

Behavioral

Monograph

#7,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

&

Fuqua,

R.

W.

(under

review).

The

case

for

total

communication:

A

behavioral

analysis

of

the

language

development

of

the

deaf.

Tweney,

R.

D.

(1979).

Reflections

on

the

history

of

behavioral

theories

of

language.

Behaviorism,

7,91-103.

Vaughan,

M.

E.,

&

Michael,

J.

L.

(in

press).

Automatic

reinforcement:

An

important

but

ignored

concept.

Behaviorism.

Wiest,

W

(1967).

Some

recent

criticisms

of

behaviorism

and

learning

theory

with

special

reference

to

Berger

and

McGaugh

and

to

Chomsky,

Psychological

Bulletin,

67,

214-225.

Winokur,

S.

(1976).

A

primerofverbal

behavior:

An

operant

analysis.

Englewood

Cliffs,

NJ:

Prentice-Hall.

Wood,

W.

S.

(1975).

What

is

"Applied"

in

the

applied

analysis

of

behavior.

In

W.

S.

Wood

(Ed.),

Issues

in

evaluating

behavior

modification.

Champaign,

IL:

Research

Press.

Wood,

W.

S.

(1981).

A

review

of

Notebooks

by

B.

F.

Skin-

ner.

The

Behavior

Analyst,

4,

157-158.

EXPERIMENTAL

AND

APPLIED

REFERENCES

Bell,

T.

M.

(1980,

May).

Early

language

training:

Establish-

ing

a

functional

verbal

repertoire.

Paper

presented

at

the

Sixth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Con-

vention,

Dearbom,

MI.

Bell,

T.

M.,

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Rueber,

T.

M.,

&

Yutzy,

R.

K.

(1979,

June).

Procedures

for

obtaining

echoic

stimulus

control

over

vocal

behavior.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Conven-

tion,

Dearborn,

MI.

Bijou,

S.

W.,

&

Baer,

D.

M.

(1965).

Child

development

II:

Universal

stage

of

infancy.

Englewood

Cliffs,

NJ:

Prentice-Hall.

Boe,

R.,

&

Winokur,

S.

A.

(1978).

A

procedure

for

study-

ing

echoic

control

in

verbal

behavior.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

30,

213-217.

Bostow,

D.

E.

(under

review).

The

experimental

analysis

of

college

instructional

practices:

Some

midcourse

corrections.

In

K.

R.

Johnson

&

P.

N.

Chase

(Eds.),

Behavior

analysis

and

complex

learning:

A

selection

of

readings

about

instructional

design.

Braam,

C.

A.,

Daeschlein,

M.,

&

Braam,

S.

J.

(1979,

June).

Mediated

transfer

in

reading

instruction

with

special

populations.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention, Dear-

born,

MI.

Braam,

S.

J.,

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Ray,

D.

A.,

Braam,

C.

A.,

Stafford,

M.

W., Rueber,

T.

M.,

Thompson,

T.,

Stang,

S.,

&

Jackson,

B.

(1979,

June).

Recent

procedural

develop-

ments

in

teaching

an

intraverbal

repertoire.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dearborn,

MI.

Braam,

S.

J.,

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Stafford,

M.

W.

(1978,

May).

Teaching

an

intraverbal

repertoire.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fourth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Chicago,

IL.

Bradford,

T.

S.,

&

Poche,

C.

E.

(1981,

May).

Establishing

verbal

behavior:

The

effects

of establishing

operations

and

imitative

prompts

to

teach

mands

to

nonverbal

elderly

retarded

persons.

Paper

presented

at

the

Sixth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Milwaukee,

WI.

Breuning,

S.

E.

(1978,

May).

The

use

of

sign

language

in

a

large

institution:

Current

research

and

implications

for

habilitation/rehabilitation.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fourth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Conven-

tion,

Chicago,

IL.

Buddenhagen,

R.

(1971).

Establishing

vocal

verbalizations

in

mute

mongoloid

children.

Champaign,

IL:

Research

Press.

Barmeier,

A.

A.

(1978,

May).

The

English

textual

repertoire

for

the

deaf.

Paper

presented

at

the

Midwestern

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Chicago,

IL.

Catania,

A.

C.,

Matthews,

B.

A.,

&

Shimoff,

E.

(1982).

Instructed

verses

shaped

human

verbal

behavior:

Interactions

with

nonverbal

responding.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

38,

233-248.

Chase,

P.

N.

(1980).

A

methodology

for

evaluating

verbal

classification

schemes

and

verbal

task

variables.

Unpub-

lished

Master's

Thesis,

University

of

Massachusetts.

Cook,

D.

N.

(1980,

May).

Identifying

the

variables

controll-

ing

verbal

behavior.

Paper

presented

at

the

Sixth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dear-

born,

MI.

Corey,

J.

R.,

&

Shamow,

J.

(1972).

The

effects

of

fading

on

the

acquisition

and

retention

of

oral

reading.

Jour-

nal

of

Applied

Behavior

Analysis,

5,

311-315.

Ferster,

C.

B.

(1967).

Arbitrary

and

natural

reinforcement.

Psychological

Record,

17,

341-347.

Ferster,

C.

B.

(1973a).

A

functional

analysis

of

depres-

sion.

American

Psychologist,

28,

857-870.

12

MARK

L.

SUNDBERG

AND

JAMES

W.

PARTINGTON

Ferster,

C.

B.

(1973b).

Behavioral

language.

International

Journal

of

Psychiatry,

11,

189-185.

Ferster,

C.

B.

(1974).

The

difference

between

behavioral

and

conventional

psychology.

The

Journal

of

Nervous

and

Mental

Disease,

159,

153-157

Ferster,

C.

B.,

&

Perrott,

M.

C.

(1962).

Behavior

principles.

New

York:

Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Goldiamond,

I.

(1977).

Literary

behavior

analysis.

Journal

of

Applied

Behavior

Analysis,

10,

527-529.

Guess,

D.,

Sailor,

W.

S.,

&

Baer,

D.

M.

(1976).

A

func-

tional

speech

and

language

training

program

for

the

severely

handicapped.

Lawrence

KS:

H

&

H

Enterprises.

Gutmann,

A.J.,

&

Rondal,

J.

A.

(1979).

Verbal

operants

in

mothers'

speech

to

nonretarded

and

Downs

Syndrome

children

matched

for

linguistic

level.

American

Journal

of

Mental

Deficiency,

83,

446-452.

Hake,

D.

F.,

&

Mabry,

J.

(1979).

Operant

and

nonoperant

responding

in

the

mynah:

Complex

schedule

control

and

deprivation

induced

responding.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

32,

305-321.

Hall,

G.,

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

&

Stafford,

M.

W.

(1979,

June).

Teaching

a

mand

repertoire

to

deaf

individuals:

The

transfer

of

stimulus

control

from

imitative

or

tact

variables

to

establishing

operations.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Conven-

tion,

Dearbom,

MI.

Hart,

B.,

&

Risley,

T.

R.

(1980).

In

vivo

language

interven-

tion:

Unanticipated

general

effects.

Journal

of

Applied

Behavior

Analysis,

13,

407-432.

Hartung,

J.

R.

(1970).

A

review

of

procedures

to

increase

the

verbal

imitation

skills

and

functional

speech

in

autistic

children.

Joumnal

of

Speech

and

Hearing

Disorders,

35,

203-217.

Harzam,

P.,

Lowe,

C.

F.,

&

Bradshaw,

M.

(1978).

Verbal

control

in

human

operant

behavior.

Psychological

Record,

28,

405-423.

Hemenway,

R.

(1975,

September).

The

controlling

relation-

ship

between

antecedent

events

and

verbal

behavior.

Paper

presented

at

the

83rd

Annual

Meeting

of

the

American

Psychological

Association,

Chicago,

IL.

Howard,

J.

S.,

Rice,

D.,

&

Pack,

L.

(1981,

May).

Establish-

ment

ofgeneralized

autoclitic

behavior

in

preschool

children.

Paper

presented

at

the

Seventh

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Milwaukee,

WI.

Hung,

D.

W.

(1980).

Training

and

generalization

of

"yes"

and

"no"

as

mands

in

two

autistic

children.

Journal

of

Autism

and

Developmental

Disorders,

10,

139-152.

Johnson,

K.

R.,

&

Chase,

P.

N.

(1979,

June).

Instructional

applications

of

B.

F.

Skinner's

analysis

of

verbal

behavior.

Worktext

for

invited

workshop

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Conven-

tion,

Dearborn,

MI.

Johnson,

K.

R.,

&

Chase,

P.

N.

(1981).

Behavior

analysis

in

instructional

design:

A

functional

typology

of

ver-

bal

tasks.

The

Behavior

Analyst,

4,

103-121.

Johnson,

K.

R.,

Chase,

P.

N.,

&

Keenan,

J.

B.

(1982,

May).

Using

Skinner's

Verbal

behavior

to

design

instruc-

tion

for

adults.

Paper

presented

at

the

Seventh

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Milwaukee,

WI.

Lahren,

B.

L.

(1975,

September).

Analysis

of

the

discriminative

control

of

controlling

variable

statements.

Paper

presented

at

the

83rd

Meeting

of

the

American

Psychological

Association,

Chicago,

IL.

Lahren,

B.

L.

(1978).

An

exploratory

functional

analysis

of

stimulus

control

in

descriptive

verbal

behavior.

Unpub-

lished

Doctoral

Dissertation,

UniversityofNeuada,

Reno.

Lee,

V.

L.

(1981).

Prepositional

phrases

spoken

and

heard.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

35,

227-242.

Lee,

V.

L.,

&

Pegler,

A.

M.

(1982).

Effects

on

spelling

of

training

children

to

read.

Journal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

37,

311-322.

Legg,

G.

E.,

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

&

Rueber,

T.

M.

(1980,

May).

Imprving

articulation

through

fingerspelling.

Paper

presented

at

the

Sixth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dearborn,

MI.

McCorkle,

M.

E.

(1978).

A

radical

behaviorist's

study

of

"woman's

experience

of

conflict."

Unpublished

Doctoral

Dissertation,

University

of

Nevada,

Reno.

Michael,

J.

L.

(1978,

May).

The

relevance

of

B.

F.

Skinner's

analysis

of

verbal

behaviorfor

the

deaf:

General

implications.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fourth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Chicago,

IL.

Mithaug,

D.

E.,

&

Wolfe,

M.

S.

(1976).

Employing

task

arrangements

and

verbal

contingencies

to

promote

verbalizations

between

retarded

children.

Journal

of

Applied

Behavior

Analysis,

9,

301-314.

Neal,

A.

(1978,

May).

The

Stokoe

notation

system:

Sign

language

and

textual

behavior.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fourth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Con-

vention,

Chicago,

IL.

O'Brien,

F.,

Azrin,

N.

H.,

&

Henson,

K.

(1969).

Increased

communications

of

chronic

mental

patients

by

reinforcement

and

response

priming.

Journal

of

Applied

Behavior

Analysis,

2,

23-29.

Paer,

J.

J.,

Plante,

W.

L.,

McLean,

L.

L.,

Olenick,

D.

L.,

Rowan,

V.

C.,

Welch,

S.

J.,

&

Werk,

S.

M.

(1979,

June).

Teaching

verbal

behavior

to

retarded

children:

An

expeimen-

tal

analysis.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dear-

born,

MI.

Plante,

W.

(1980). Tacting

and

manding:

Transfer

of

verbal

responses across

two

different

response

classes

in

a

retarded

child.

Unpublished

Master's

Thesis,

University

of

Manitoba.

Parrott,

L.

J.

(1979).

Modifying

the

behavior

of

audiences.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dearborn,

MI.

Partington

J.

W.,

&

Bailey,

J.

S.

(1980,

May).

Teaching

an

intraverbal

repertoire

to

normal

preschool

children.

Paper

presented

at

the

Sixth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dearbom,

MI.

Peterson,

N.

(1978,

May).

Verbal

behavior.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fourth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Chicago,

IL.

Reynolds,

N.

J.,

&

Risley,

T.

R.

(1968).

The

role

of

social

and

material

reinforcers

in

increasing

talking

of

a

disadvantaged

preschool

child.

Journal

of

Applied

Behavior

Analysis,

1,

253-262.

Rueber,

T.

M.,

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

&

Legg,

G.

E.

(1980,

May).

Improving

articulation

and

facilitation

of

echoic

to

tact

transfer

of

stimulus

control

through

fingerspelling.

Paper

presented

at

the

Sixth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dearborn,

MI.

Salzinger,

K.

(1959).

Experimental

manipulation

of

ver-

bal

behavior:

A

review.

Journal

of

General

Psychology,

61,

64-94.

Salzinger,

K.,

&

Salzinger,

K.

S.

(Eds.).

(1967).

Research

in

vrbal

behavior

and

some

neurophysiological

implications.

New

York:

Academic

Press.

Salzinger,

K.,

&

Walker,

M.

B.

(1962).

The

operant

con-

trol

of

vocalization

in

the

dog.

Joumal

of

the

Experimental

Analysis

of

Behavior,

5,

383-389.

SKINNER'S

VERBAL

BEHAVIOR:

A

REFERENCE

LIST

13

Salzinger,

K.

S.,

Salzinger,

K.,

Portnoy,

S.,

Eckman,

J.,

Bacon,

P.

N.,

Dentsch.

M.,

&

Zubin,

J.

(1962).

Operant

conditioning

of

continuous

speech

in

children.

Child

Development,

33,

683-695.

Simic,

J.,

&

Butcher,

B.

(1980).

Development

of

spon-

taneous

manding

in

languag

deficient

children.

Jour-

nal

of

Applied

Behavior

Analysis,

13,

523-528.

Sloane,

H.

N.

Jr.,

Johnson,

M.

R.,

&

Harris,

F.

R.

(1968).

Remedial

procedures

for

teaching

verbal

behavior

to

speech

deficient

or

defective

young

children.

In

H.

N.

Sloane

Jr.,

&

B.

D.

MacAulay,

(Eds.),

Operant

procedures

in

remedial

speech

and

language

training.

Boston:

Houghton

Mifflin.

Sloane,

H.

N.

Jr.,

&

MacAulay,

B.

D.

(Eds.),

(1968).

Operant

procedures

in

remedial

speech

and

language

train-

ing.

Boston:

Houghton

Mifflin.

Spooner,

D.

(1975,

August).

The

identification

of

controll-

ing

variables:

An

analysis

of

some

recorded

verbal

behavior.

Workshop

conducted

presented

at

the

83rd

Annual

Meeting

of

the

American

Psychological

Association,

Chicago,

IL.

Spradlin,

J.

E.

(1963).

Assessment

of

speech

and

language

of

retarded

children:

The

Parsons

Language

Sample.

In

R.

L.

Schiefelbusch,

(Ed.),

Language

studies

of

mentally

retarded

children.

Journal

of

Speech

and

Hearing

Disorders

Monograph,

10,

8-31.

Spradlin

J.

E.

(1966).

Environmental

factors

and

the

language

development

of

retarded

children.

In

S.

Ros-

enberg

(Ed.),

Developments

in

applied

psycholinguistic

research

(pp.

261-290),

Riverside,

NJ:

The

Macmillian

Co.

Spradlin,

J.

E.

(1967).

Procedures

for

evaluating

pro-

cesses

associated

with

receptive

and

expressive

lan-

guage.

In

R.

L.

Schiefelbusch,

R.

Copeland,

&

J.

Smith

(Eds.),

Language

and

Mental

Retardation

(pp.

118-136),

New

York:

Holt,

Rinehart,

and

Winston.

Stafford,

M.

W.,

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

&

Braam,

S.

J.

(1978,

May).

An

experimental

analysis

of

the

distinction

between

mands

and

tacts.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fourth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Chicago,

IL.

Sundberg,

M.

L.

(1980).

A

program

for

teaching

a

ver-

bal

repertoire

to

persons

in

whom

language

is

absent

of

defective.

Western

Michigan

University

Behavioral

Monograph

#6,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Sundberg,

M.

L.

(1980).

The

role

of

automatic

reinforce-

ment

in

early

laa

development.

Western

Michigan

University

Behavioral

Monograph

#2,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Sundberg,

M.

L.

(1980).

Developing

a

verbal

rpeoire

using

sign

language

and

Skinner's

analysis

of

verbal

behavior.

Unpublished

Doctoral

Disseration,

Western

Michigan

University.

Sundberg,

M.

L.

(in

press).

Language.

In

J.

L.

Matson,

&

S.

E.

Breuning

(Eds.),

Assessing

the

mentally

retarded.

New

York:

Grune

and

Stratton.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

&

Michael,

J.

L.

(1980,

September).

Teaching

a

sign

language

verbal

repertoire:

The

establish-

ment

and

transfer

of

stimulus

control.

Paper

presented

at

the

88th

Annual

Meeting

of

the

American

Psychological

Association,

Montreal,

Quebec.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Michael,

J.

L.,

&

Peterson,

N.

(1976,

May).

An

introduction

the

use

of

American

Sign

Language.

Workshop

conducted

at

the

Second

Annual

Mid-

westem

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Conven-

tion,

Chicago,

IL.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Milani,

I.,

&

Partington,

J.

W.

(1977,

August).

The

use

of

sign

language

with

hearing

mentally

impaired

persons.

Paper

presented

at

the

85th

Annual

meeting

of

the

American

Psychological

Association,

San

Franciso,

CA.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Ray,

D.

A.,

Braam,

S.

J.,

Stafford,

M.

W.,

Rueber,

T.

M.,

&

Braam,

C.

A.

(1980).

A

manual

for

the

use

of

B.

F.

Skinner's

analysis

of

verbal

behavior

for

language

assessment

and

programming.

Western

Michigan

University

Behavioral

Monograph

#9,

Kalamazoo,

MI.

Sundberg,

M.

L.,

Stafford,

M.

W.,

&

Meyer,

J.

(1979,

June).

The

effects

offingerspelling

on

articulation.

Paper

presented

at

the

Fifth

Annual

Association

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dearbom,

MI.

Vargas,

J.

S.

(1978).

A

behavioral

approach

to

the

teaching

of

composition.

The

BehaviorAnalyst,

1,

16-24.

Wallace,

I.,

&

Pear,

J.

J.

(1977).

Self-control

techniques

of

famous

novelists.

Journal

of

Applied

BehaviorAnalysis,

10,

515-525.

Yutzy,

R.

K.,

Rueber,

T.

M.,

&

Stafford,

M.

W.

(1980,

May).

A

comparison

of

mand

verses

tact

training

pro-

cedures.

Paper

presented

at

the

Sixth

Annual

Associa-

tion

for

Behavior

Analysis

Convention,

Dearborn,

MI.

... Certainly the terminological revision satisfied Jack's (probably mild) unease with what he considered an insufficient mechanism to classify particular verbal operant relations involving sign language. But this clarification and its forerunners via university lectures and other presentations (e.g., Sundberg, Michael, & Peterson, 1977; also see Sundberg & Partington, 1982 surely served to enhance the design and analysis of applied programs that incorporated signed responses as the dependent variable form to teach a wide variety of individuals with language deficits, (e.g., Braam & Poling, 1983;Hall & Sundberg, 1987;Stafford et al., 1988;Sundberg, 1983a). For additional discussions of critical program considerations influenced by Jack, see Sundberg (1980, and Sundberg and Partington (1998). ...

... Verbal Behav (2016) 32:275-323 301 The genesis of this interest in sign language vis-à-vis Skinner's (1957) analysis of verbal behavior, as well as applied work in the area of developmental disabilities, may have been his collaboration with University of Houston colleague, Lee Meyerson, a relationship that proved productive (see . The impact of Skinner's Verbal Behavior (1957) on Jack and on many of his students is chronicled in two important reference lists that highlight the body of work that ensued (see Sundberg & Partington, 1982; entries are catalogued according to "Conceptual," "Experimental," and "Applied" references). ...

"In the late 1950's, Jack Michael, a bright but irritating young psychology instructor, moved from the Universities of Kansas to Houston to Arizona State. Along the way he befriended two nontraditional students, protected them through their Ph.D. programs, and turned them loose on the world: Teodoro Ayllon…and Montrose Wolf…" (Risley, 2001, p. 267). So begins Risley's chapter on the origins of applied behavior analysis. For almost 50 years, Jack Michael provided a model for us to "talk like Skinner" and to analyze behavior as Skinner would. For this, he has been widely respected and revered. The purpose of this bibliography is to explain to new and familiar readers alike Jack's contributions to the field of behavior analysis in areas of his primary focus: (a) behavioral function taxonomy, (b) motivation, (c) reinforcement, (d) response topographies, (e) multiple control, (f) duplic and codic verbal behavior, and (g) teaching. Throughout, we weave his role in the field's history and his leadership in its expansion, as these have been additional areas of significant contributions. Above all, we wish to highlight Jack's work, in bibliographic and narrative form, in a way that expresses a heartfelt tribute on behalf of his students and others whom he influenced to learn about psychology as a natural science and to think and talk like Skinner.

... Over 60 years have passed since the publication of Verbal Behavior, and The Analysis of Verbal Behavior (TAVB) has been in existence for more than half of that time. A common task in the history of this journal has been to take stock-some of the first articles were reference lists (e.g., Sundberg & Partington, 1982, 1983, identifying publications and presentations that had used Skinner's analysis of verbal behavior, and charting the growth in those publications. Twenty years ago, TAVB partially dedicated a special issue considering the status and future of verbal behavior research, and the editorial team today has been asked to consider the same kinds of questions as we look ahead to the future: Where do we see the field moving over the next decade? ...

  • Siri Ming Siri Ming

As a member of the incoming editorial team, I have been asked to speak to the future of verbal behavior research and of The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, considering questions about the direction of the field, the future path of the journal, and the message I would have for the next generation of researchers. In considering these questions, I propose that we ground strategic decision-making processes in values of collaboration and inclusivity, toward valued outcomes that include diversity and innovation, which I see as necessary for improving both practice and conceptual understanding, the traditionally stated aims of this community.

... For example, our initial research on stimulus-stimulus pairing and automatic reinforcement was conducted at KVMC, fulfilling one of my PhD competency requirements (Sundberg, 1978b). (For a listing of several other studies conducted at KVMC and other WMU practicum sites, as well as other early VB presentations and publications, see Sundberg & Partington, 1982, 1983 Conducting VB Workshops Jack enjoyed teaching, and conducting VB workshops around the country provided him an opportunity to further disseminate behavior analysis and VB. In 1977, Jack and I were invited to Helena, Montana, where a few WMU students had acquired jobs. ...

  • Mark L Sundberg Mark L Sundberg

Jack Michael offered a course on verbal behavior almost every year throughout his teaching career. Jack was also interested in the application of Skinner's work and in 1976 began to offer a graduate course at Western Michigan University titled Verbal Behavior Applications. Jack and his students pursued the application of Skinner's work on verbal behavior with dozens of empirical studies during the 1970s. In honor of the 60th anniversary of the publication of Skinner's book Verbal Behavior, the current paper presents some of my recollections of Jack's work on verbal behavior as his student, graduate teaching assistant, and research collaborator during that time period.

... Verbal behavior is a theoretical perspective focused on a behavioral, or functional, classification of language that operates on the idea that language develops under the same behavioral principles as other non-verbal behaviors (e.g., grasping, crawling, walking). Thus, language is a learned behavior that involves social interaction between a speaker and a listener who reinforces the spoken language (Skinner 1957;Sundberg and Partington 1982). This assessment and curriculum guide has three levels, with a variety of skills itemized per domain for each level. ...

The extant literature on social communication interventions for young children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has been well reviewed. However, current reviews of the literature indicate more research is needed on advanced social skills for young children with ASD. These more complex social skills, such as sustaining a conversation, showing empathy, or telling a joke, are critical for peer acceptance in the elementary school years. In the current paper, we reviewed the existing single-case literature on social communication interventions for advanced social skills for young (4–12-year-old) children with ASD. We define advanced social skills using the task analysis of the Social Behavior and Social Play—Level 3 subsection of the Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program (VB-MAPP). Electronic database searches of Education Resources Information Center (ERIC), Academic Search Premier, and PsycINFO were conducted. Results revealed a library of useful interventions for a specific set of social communication skills; however, some crucial skills for children with ASD were missing from the results. Directions for future research and practice are discussed.

... Most of these studies were theses and dissertations supervised by Jack Michael, and were presented at the MABA/ABA conventions during that time period. A listing of many of these studies can be found in the journal The Analysis of Verbal Behavior (Sundberg & Partington, 1982, 1983. The "Lovaas method" was clearly more popular than VB, but VB has existed all along. ...

Presents an interview with the experts on the topics related to the verbal behavior and its application to individuals with autism.

... Last year Sundberg and Partington (1982) presented a list of 136 references relevant to Skinner's book Verbal Behavior. Since that time a substantial number of new references have become available. ...

  • Vicki L. Lee

This paper offers some comments about the subject matter of Skinner's book Verbal Behavior (1957). It first presents an argument against the common misconception that Verbal Behavior is about language. It then discusses the nature of verbal behavior as a subdivision of operant behavior. Following that, the paper identifies three aspects of the concept of verbal behavior that need some clarification. Finally, the paper concludes by pointing out that the significance of Verbal Behavior lies most centrally in its effort to offer a better way of talking about one part of psychology's subject matter.

  • Adair McPherson
  • Marilyn Bonem
  • Gina Green
  • J. Grayson Osborne

The influence of Skinner's Verbal Behavior on the generation of verbal behavior research was examined in a citation analysis that counted the citations of the book from January 1957 to August 1983 and described the fields in which the citations occurred. In a subsequent content analysis, citations were classified as directly influenced by the book if they selected at least one of Skinner's classes of verbal behavior for empirical examination. Directly influenced citations were sorted as descriptive, applied, or basic. The total number of citations of the book (836), the increasing annual number of citations, and the range of fields in which the book has been cited are evidence of its broad influence. However, empirical investigations employing at least one of Skinner's classes of verbal behavior are only a small proportion (31/836) of the citations. Of this small proportion an even smaller number constitutes experimental analyses (19/836). The small proportion of empirical studies suggests that Verbal Behavior is primarily cited for reasons other than as source material for research hypotheses in the study of verbal behavior. Some speculations are offered to account for the book's limited influence on research.

The present study undertook an updated citation analysis of Skinner's (1957)Verbal Behavior. All articles that cited Verbal Behavior between 1984 and 2004 were recorded and content analyzed into one of five categories; four empirical and one nonempirical. Of the empirical categories, studies that employed a verbal operant from Skinner's analysis were assigned to either basic, applied, or observational categories. Empirical studies that did not employ a verbal operant were categorized as other-empirical. The total number of citations remained stable across the review period and averaged just over 52 per year. Of these, 80% were from nonempirical articles, 13.7% were from other-empirical articles, 4% were from applied articles, 1.4% were from basic articles, and 0.9% were from observational articles. An "obliteration" analysis was also conducted to identify articles that employed Skinner's verbal operant terms but did not cite Verbal Behavior. This analysis identified 44 additional articles, suggesting that a degree of obliteration had occurred in the half century since the publication of Verbal Behavior. In particular, the analysis suggests that the verbal operant of manding has sufficient presence in the applied empirical literature to render citation of Verbal Behavior redundant. Overall, Verbal Behavior continues to make an important contribution to the psychological literature.

This paper introduces the nature and practice of bibliography (e.g., definition, history, and genres); it reviews the extant B. F. Skinner bibliographies (1958 to 2001); and it describes the methods used in constructing a new, comprehensive, and corrected bibliography of Skinner's primary-source published works. The bibliography includes 291 items from across 16 categories of publications (e.g., books, articles, chapters, monographs, book reviews, manuals, encyclopedia entries, letters to the editor) and lists them in chronological order (1930 to 1999). A discussion section addresses the bibliography's limitations, how it might be enlarged and expanded, its value for qualitative and quantitative historical inquiry, and the beginnings of a "Skinner industry."